‘The Heart Wants What It Wants’: You Season 4 Opens With an Icky (and Misinterpreted) Quote

‘The Heart Wants What It Wants’: You Season 4 Opens With an Icky (and Misinterpreted) Quote

February 10, 2023 Off By dana2726

Anyone who’s seen You— the darkly comical thriller that was cancelled on Lifetime prior to relocating to Netflix and ending up being a big hit– can inform you a couple of things with certainty about protagonist Joe Goldberg (Penn Badgley).

First: Joe is a stalker. 2nd: Joe is … well, Joe is a killer. We can’t dispute these things! There’s one more unassailable reality: Joe is a well-read, knowledgeable person. It’s real! Joe Goldberg consists of plethoras, sorry to state it folks. He’s a stalker/murderer who’s clever, stays up to date with present occasions and cultural discussions, and has taste in literature.

This whole dynamic is completely encapsulated in the opening line of You‘s 4th season, as the episode “Joe Takes a Holiday” opens with Joe right away getting our attention by pricing quote somebody putting rather the twist on somebody else’s quote: “As a troublesome male appropriating a queer poet when stated: The heart desires what it desires.”

Yikes. Let’s go into that a person a bit, shall we?

Who stated “The Heart Wants What It Wants”?

Let’s go through Joe’s quote one piece at a time. The initial origin of ‘The Heart Wants What It Wants” originates from a letter that poet Emily Dickinson sent out to Mary Bowles, other half of Samuel Bowles, who was the publisher and editor of a paper called The Springfield Republican in between 1844 and1878

Dickinson’s letter, dated Spring 1862, opens with the following line:

” When the very best is gone

I understand that other things are not of repercussion

The Heart desires what it desires

otherwise it does not care”

In describing Dickinson as “queer,” Joe is taking a leap into what’s been a long-gestating dispute surrounding the famously-reclusive poet’s personal life, stemming mainly from a letter she composed to her sister-in-law, Susan Gilbert Her sexuality has actually long referred dispute, however lots of academics, such as this research study from UNC Greensboro, recommend that “throughout Emily Dickinson’s publishing history there are proofs of mindsets on the part of her household, her editors, and her critics, all of which might be described by the theory that the poet was homosexual. This theory is validated when one analyzes the letters and poems.”

Now, we should recognize the “troublesome” guy who Joe recommends appropriated Dickinson’s language. Which male is Academy Award-winning filmmaker Woody Allen.

amazon lionsgate with the cinema society host the new york premiere of

Jamie McCarthy// Getty Images

Allen, best understood for composing and directing films like Annie Hall and Midnight In Paris, has actually come under public analysis for various factors, most especially being implicated of sexually abusing his stepdaughter and weding Soon-Yi Previn, who is the embraced child of his previous long time romantic partner, Mia Farrow.

Allen’s usage of “the heart desires what it desires” in fact was available in direct action to questioning around his relationship with Previn. In a 2001 interview with TIME, Allen– then 65– was asked whether he considered his relationship with Previn– then 31– to be “a healthy, equivalent relationship

He reacted:

Well, who understands? It’s completely healthy. I do not believe equivalent is always a desideratum. In some cases equality in a relationship is fantastic, in some cases inequality makes it work. It’s an equal-opportunity relationship. I suggest, I’m not equivalent to her in specific methods.

The heart desires what it desires. There’s no reasoning to those things. You fulfill somebody and you fall in love which’s that.

It’s sensible to presume that Dickinson’s words were not initially meant to be utilized in this context.

How does this all suit You Season 4?

you penn badgley as joe goldberg in episode 401 of you cr courtesy of netflix © 2022

Netflix

Glad you asked. This referral to open the season is, really, a relatively ideal encapsulation of Joe Goldberg as a character, and establishes his main internal battle of both the season and the series as a whole. Joe is an exceptionally thoughtful, and, for the a lot of part, self-aware individual. His narrative is frequently smart, amusing, and extremely watchful. Regardless of the awful things we’ve seen him do over the course of the program, we still discover ourselves together with him for the flight.

Even in this opening, he draws in between the presumed “bad people”– Allen is referred to as a “bothersome guy”– and, we suggest, the individual providing the message and making the judgment– Joe himself.

Joe knows enough to comprehend this, however, as in the remainder of the Season 4 Part 1 Episodes, and, truly, whatever we’ve seen to this point, he has one significant blind area: once again, himself. His narrative and whatever he ever states to his foes, whether it’s Love Quinn or the Eat the Rich Killer, is that, regardless of his stalking, regardless of his killing, he’s not like them. He’s much better.

And that’s where the battle lies. Is he much better? Is he truly? That much stays to be seen.

preview for Liam Neeson | Don't Read The Comments

Headshot of Evan Romano

Evan Romano

Evan is the culture editor for Men’s Health, with bylines in The New York Times, MTV News, Brooklyn Magazine, and VICE. He likes odd motion pictures, enjoys excessive television, and listens to music regularly than he does not.

Read More